The plate section planned for Spite Work

As a freelancer, you typically do your own photo research. My books about the poet Weldon Kees and the daughter of Walter Gropius, Alma Mahler, and Franz Werfel, Manon Gropius,  have balanced and informative plate sections that illustrate the various stages of their lives and milieus.  A book that incorporates the life of Virginia Rappe and presents both her victimology and Roscoe Arbuckle’s offers some challenges. She was a model and an actress—and all of her photographs are staged. And this is true of Arbuckle as a motion picture comedian.

Certain photographes, however, would have a special place in Spite Work. During his opening argument for the People at the third trial, Assistant District Attorney Milton U’Ren handed a photograph taken by Lillian Blake at her San Francisco studio in September 1914. I would love to have this one for the book. U’Ren describes it as a “clipping,” evidence that Miss Rappe had been in San Francisco at the time and to reiterate a long-held contention throughout the Arbuckle case, that she was a healthy, vibrant young woman and had never suffered from a “lasting disease” as Arbuckle’s insisted. “No one can go through life doubled up with pain, holding their abdomen, and moaning and crying,” U’Ren said, as the jurors passed around the image, “without it appearing upon their face, that picture, as well as the report of the commission, and the report of the Doctors who examined the organs of Miss Rappe.”

Virginia had been in San Francisco in the late summer of 1914. But I have not yet located this photograph. Too, I have to be conscious of U’Ren’s use of the word  “clipping,” which does not necessarily mean a newspaper clipping. His choice of that word also meant a cropped image, intended as a close-up, suitable for framing, as it were. The Blake studio image was not a modeling session. It was for personal use, not unlike a latter-day carte de visite, intended for a friend, a family member, or a paramour. That said, there are plenty of possible clippings that date from 1915, none of which were taken at the Blake studio at the southwest corner of Geary and Grant.

So, I have to consider that U’Ren could have backdated two recent acquisitions from an August 1915 shoot, taken by a staff photographer for the San Francisco Bulletin to illustrate this full-page feature devoted to Virginia’s fashion designs, which she modeled at the Fairmount Hotel while attending and promoting herself at the Panama–Pacific International Exposition.


From the San Francisco Bulletin, August 7, 1915 (Newspapers.com)

The above “evidence” was not used at the trial, even though the prosecutors would have found more proof that Virginia was healthy enough not only to be in San Francisco for two months, but healthy enough to let a rumor fly that she was engaged to an Argentine diplomat, Alberto d’Alkaine. He was also present in San Francisco, breaking ground for the Argentine pavilion in 1914. There paths likely crossed at the time and the Lillian Blake photograph may have been for his delectation.

The following image, which is one of the acquisitions, has some forensic value, given the circles around Virginia’s eyes. The image, incidentally, also pretends to be a closeup of the subject (and a thumbtack, too).


Virginia Rappe did not have “racoon eyes.” She had other issues discussed in the work-in-progress.

Virginia Rappe as ur-fashionista

During the third Arbuckle trial, in early April 1922, the prosecution called a surprise witness to the stand, Lillian Blake, a San Francisco photographer who claimed to have taken a single photograph of Virginia Rappe in September 1914. She testified that Rappe had spent about thirty minutes in her Geary Street studio.

Her purpose was to rebut the testimony of a defense witness, Helen Whitehurst, who claimed that Rappe attended her birthday party in Chicago in October 1914, where she drank an alcoholic beverage and fell ill. Arbuckle’s lawyers hoped to prove that she had a long history of exhibiting such symptoms as abdominal pain, hysterics, and tearing off her clothes, triggered by the effects of alcohol. These were the same symptoms she presented at the comedian’s Labor Day party on September 5, 1921.

Prosecutors contended that Rappe wasn’t in Chicago. Another of their witnesses said she was in New York during the autumn of 1914. A third also said San Francisco. Naturally, Arbuckle’s lawyer, Gavin McNab, used this confusion to his advantage. He asked the jury: How could Rappe be in two places at once? McNab could see the prosecutors were floundering. Their witnesses lacked credibility and the evidence was weak. As further proof that Rappe had been, at least, on the West Coast in late 1914, Blake held up an undated newspaper clipping of her photograph. She didn’t have an original.

We dug deeply for a source for that photo as we began to revise the work-in-progress. The problem was that Rappe wasn’t newsworthy on the west coast in 1914—except when she returned from abroad during the first week of January. She and another model made a splash when they exposed the frills and a good portion of the leggings of their long underwear or “pantalets.” Photographs of the pair aboard the SS Baltic appeared in U.S. newspapers for two months. Then she disappeared, leaving a void that Arbuckle’s lawyers filled with physicians who said they treated her and alleged companions in Chicago whose real lives proved to be, if we could use a contemporary expression, “sketchy.”

In the spring of 1915, however, Rappe’s image was again seen in newspapers across the nation as she began to publicize her new line of clothes. She also appeared in the society pages of some American newspapers in connection to her short-lived engagement to the Argentine diplomat Don Alberto d’Alkaine, who oversaw his nation’s pavilion at the 1915 Panama-Pacific International Exposition.

This made us question whether the prosecution co-opted one of these images to convict Arbuckle? We probably won’t ever know. But thanks to having more recently digitized and searchable San Francisco newspapers archives, we did uncover a little more of Rappe’s deeper connection to San Francisco and it does go back to September 1914. We discovered that Rappe’s liaison with d’Alkaine began around that time. The clue is a story in a front-page feature published in the San Francisco Bulletin in late July 1915. A week later, it was followed by a full-page spread devoted to Rappe’s design collection—and fashion advice.

What one can see below is that Rappe was committed to and invested in designing all kinds of outfits for women. So, why did she give it up—as well as d’Alkaine—for a precarious existence as merely the “best-dressed woman in Hollywood”?

Source: Newspapers.com.

Source: Newspapers.com.